Ultimate track tire guide | 200tw, 100tw, street-legal track, R-comp | Articles


[Editor’s note: While this guide first appeared in our August 2021 issue, updates will made as new tires enter our market.]

The biggest variable in performance? Tires.

But which ones are the perfect match? It depends on the car choice, setup, rules, venue, weather and driving style. Budget and longevity can also influence this decision.

We’re here to help with a synopsis of available options, culled from all our years of tire testing. If you can’t find shoes that fit here, they probably don’t exist.

All the tires listed here are DOT-approved, which means they can legally be driven on the street—even if that’s not a great idea. (We’re looking at you, Hoosier.)

While today’s market concentrates on the 200tw Extreme Performance category that’s so prevalent in autocross, time trials and endurance racing, we branched out to include faster tires that aren’t limited by that UTQG figure. To make this guide easy to follow, we’ve grouped tires by their intended mission. Happy shopping.

Super 200s

These are fast tires for autocross and single-lap time trials that meet the 200tw ratings. All are capable of a fairly similar single-lap time trial or autocross pace, though each goes about it in different ways.

Yokohama Advan A052

We list this one first since it’s the reigning king of the Super 200s, but it comes with caveats. To perform optimally, it needs lots of camber and wheel width. It also benefits from shallower tread depth to help mitigate its tendency to quickly overheat when pressed hard. And finally, it’s expensive and only available in select sizes. But if your application meets those requirements, and your driving skill allows you to lay down that one perfect lap, then this is your droid. A note about that heat intolerance: This tire doesn’t need any heat to activate—first turn, it sticks. It’s even good in the wet, so long as there’s no significant standing water to cause hydroplaning.

Bridgestone Potenza RE-71R

For many, this was the go-to alternative to the Yokohama. Super-responsive, it could dance around cones or dive to apexes with telepathic instincts. Just think about turning, and it would react. Its super-stiff sidewalls also allowed fat tires to be successfully pinched onto narrow wheels—a reality in some race classes. And while it needed a little bit of heat for the compound to work, it could deliver a number of autocross runs or road course circuits at max attack. It’s even been used to win in 8-hour endurance racing competition. Sadly, this tire is no longer in production, but many sizes still exist at retail in large enough quantity for it to remain an option for some time.

BFGoodrich g-Force Rival S 1.5

Before the A052 stole the show, the big battle was BFG versus Bridges- tone. The Rival needs a little more heat to work, but stays in the game even longer than the RE-71R. This is great for lapping or two-driver autocrossing, but a little tricky for cold and or wet days. And while not as crisp as the Bridgestone, the BFG allows one to drive at larger slip angles seemingly with impunity.

Falken Azenis RT660

Exit Bridgestone, enter Falken. Indeed, they look alike, and to a large degree they perform alike. The RT660 has a fairly similar responsiveness to the RE-71R, though not quite as crisp. For many, this is a good thing as the tire tends to not be as edgy, allowing for mid-corner corrections to be made. Like the Bridgestone, the Azenis compound needs just a little bit of heat to turn on, but hangs in there for many laps or runs. It’s a great choice for lapping, time trials or autocrossing. Oh, and it has some of the most favorable pricing of the bunch.

Kumho ECSTA V730

Added September 2021

We really like the new V730 as it does indeed honor the traditional Kumho characteristics for drivability, consistency and longevity. While not the quickest on single-lap pace, it is right in the mix and gives many chances at nailing great laps any time in a session–call it nearly as quick as the Falken Azenis RT660 and almost as consistent as the Hankook Ventus R-S4–so, basically, another contender.

Goodyear Eagle F1 SuperCar 3

Responsiveness of the Goodyear is similar to the Rival S, but grip turns on quicker and stays active lap after lap. Note that the smaller sizes of this tire (sub-265mm section) come molded deeper and with more void, so they don’t perform quite as well. This is a great triple-threat tire: cones, laps, daily.

Michelin Pilot Sport Cup 2 Connect (240)

OE fitment on some of the world’s fastest sports cars, the SC2 has been a staple of the track day scene for many years. The move from the 180-treadwear rating of the old Cup 2 to this tire’s 240 rating, it should be noted, is more of a marketing change than a performance one. Think of it as a positive iteration of both grip and consistency/longevity through technology. In short, this tire is no slower than its predecessor, despite moving out of the Track Use only category. Its main attribute? Grip. Lots of it. That said, it can let go in a hurry if you ask for too much. But for most folks, it will deliver lap after lap of enjoyment.

Nankang CR-1

Nankang was able to create a worthy competitor to the Yokohama A052. While response is similarly vague, grip is outstanding. That said, it has the same trait of quickly heat-soaking when loaded hard. Perhaps its best feature is that there are some very motorsports-oriented niche sizes available, like the 245/40R15 that we recently tested.

Dunlop Direzza ZIII

The Dunlop ZIII might be an older 200tw tire, but Tire Rack still moves a lot of them. Why? Price and available sizes, as it comes in a Miata-friendly 195/50R15. This is also a good choice for dual use, with solid performance in both wet and dry conditions. We last tested it in 2018, and the Dunlop ran within a half-second of both the RE-71R and Rival S 1.5.

Toyo Proxes R1R

This tire is long in the tooth, but still a viable choice for triple duty. The R1R was once the darling of the autocross world, especially in the magical 195/50R15 sizing. Its excellent grip and tossability still delivers strong performance value in the canyons, around the cones, and hitting apexes. You might not win a national championship, but you’ll smile every time you turn the wheel.

Endurance 200s

These tires trade some speed for consistency and long life while still meeting the 200tw requirements. Running endurance races? Looking to get a full season out of a single set of 200tw tires? Might want to start the search here.

Hankook Ventus RS-4

All hail the king of grassroots endurance racing. No tire has racked up more enduro wins or led more laps than the RS-4. It’s the gold standard against which all others are measured. Wears like iron, but can still deliver a pace that’s within a second or two of the Super 200s—and do so all day long. It does need some heat to come in, but loves living in the furnace of heavy lateral loading. This also makes it ideal for weekly lapping sessions where no trophies are on the line. The only downside is that Han- kook tends to sell out of popular sizes every year in the fall, though usually replenishes stock in the spring.

Maxxis Victra VR-1

While able to match the Hankook RS-4 on single lap pace and durability, the VR-1 is not quite as consistent over the long haul. It’s a great alternative when the RS-4 is sold out, though.

BFGoodrich g-Force Rival

This was BFG’s original entry into the 200tw category, but was superseded by the Rival S when Bridgestone raised the bar. With the rise of amateur endurance racing, however, BFG has put the original Rival back into production. Driving feel is a little more direct than the Hankook, but pace, consistency and longevity are all on par with the RS-4.

Falken Azenis RT615K+

As the final installment in the decade-old 615 line, this tire blends a nice mix of dry and wet performance, with solid wear characteristics. A little loud on the street, but it’s right at home delivering lots of track laps or autocross runs. While supplanted by the RT660 in overall pace, the RT-615K+ remains a popular choice for dual-duty or endurance use.

Valino VR08GP

If you want a set of tires that will deliver a full year of use, this Valino offering makes a great option. Our test showed imperceptible wear and great handling traits, though not nearly as much grip as the others in the category. Pricing is also friendly.

Michelin Pilot Sport 4S

One tire to work in all conditions, one tire to rule them all. This is the one. If the ground’s not frozen, this tire will perform. Cold and damp? Got you covered. Standing water? No problem. Warm and dry? Still quick. Chosen each year by the majority of the field for the Tire Rack One Lap of America, this tire can easily put down quick laps at every venue regardless of the weather—and still do the 3800 miles of transit needed for the week without a hint of drama. Steering response is massively authoritative, although the tire can be a little edgy at the limit as it heats up in dry lapping conditions. Available in a huge variety of sizes, including many OE fitments. Its price matches its capabilities.

Continental ExtremeContact Sport

Our testing put the Conti ECS just slightly behind the Michelin PS4S in both dry and wet grip, but ahead in its ability to cut through standing water. The Conti’s steering response feels a bit vague and it doesn’t last as long as the Michelin, but it’s also priced substantially lower.

Continental ExtremeContact Force

So new that we haven’t tested it yet: Continental and Hoosier have teamed up to offer the ExtremeContact Force, a 200tw endurance tire.

Cooper RS3-R and RS3-RS

Cooper Tire supports the World Racing League and also offers two endurance—specific tires: the RS3-R (260tw intended for dry conditions) and RS3-RS (220tw for the wet). GRM test to come.

Endurance 100s

This category is a tick faster than the Endurance 200s, yet still in it for the long haul. While these tires don’t meet the 200tw requirement often found in endurance racing, they can still work for those doing lap days.

Nankang AR-1

Although it’s rated at 100tw, this one has all the traits of a solid 200tw tire. Pace is on par with most of that bunch, as is the typical output pattern of a single fast lap, followed by a number of laps at about a half-second slower pace. Feel is similar to the Goodyear SC3 or Rival S. Note that this tire benefits from a good heat cycle before delivering optimal performance.

Nitto NT01

Like the Nankang AR-1, this is another 100tw track day special that delivers on par with today’s Super-200s for single-lap pace. But it can repeat that trick lap after lap, session after session—all the way to the cords. Sizing and availability are somewhat limited, but it’s still a favorite among many track rats.

Toyo Proxes RA-1

The same parent company owns both Nitto and Toyo, with the Toyo RA-1 essentially a Nitto NT-01 with a different tread design—and a very clever one at that. When run at full-tread depth of 8/32 inch, it cuts through water with ease. Shaving to 6/32 improves dry traction and consistency. At 4/32, the lateral grooves disappear, while optimal dry performance comes at 3/32 where only two circumferential grooves remain.

Toyo Proxes R888R

Another popular tire for lapping, this one comes in a huge variety of sizes. Like the NT-01, pace is on par with the Super 200s, but consistency is the real game here. Just don’t get caught out in a storm, as the tread pattern is optimized for dry use only.

Toyo Proxes RR

This is Toyo’s ultimate expression of a DOT-legal tire optimized for competition use only. With a lightweight casing, 4/32-inch tread depth and a slick tread pattern, it wears its “Not for Highway Use” markings proudly. Even though it’s rated at only 40tw, it performs on par with the others in our Endurance 100 grouping. NASA even allows it to compete as a 100tw in their Super Touring and Time Trials classes.

Maxxis Victra RC-1

The Victra RC-1 from Maxxis wears a semi-slick tread yet still carries a DOT rating. Save this one for dry track events, its manufacturer says. Available sizes start with the ever-popular 205/50R15 and run up through a 275/35R18.

Street-legal Track

This category consists of DOT-approved track and autocross tires not saddled with a 200tw rating. Tired of pointing folks by? Looking to embarrass better machinery? Bolt on a set of these and win that next track day.

Goodyear Eagle F1 SuperCar 3R

This one is magic, simply magic. All the great traits of its 220tw cousin, plus a compound that hooks like a major league curve baller. Braking, forward bite, lateral grip—it does it all at the highest level and continues to deliver for entire sessions, though the first lap or two are typically the quickest. As with a racing slick, you’ll need to put some significant energy into the tire before full commitment, though. But it’s a small price to pay for such a big payoff.

Pirelli P Zero Trofeo R

This one is a little fuzzy, since so many of the size offerings are OE fitments with very specific characteristics that vary from standard. We tested the generic version and found it to be on pace with the Goodyear SC3R for a single magic lap, but then a bit of a fall-off ensued. The Pirelli was also less forgiving.

R-Comps

When it comes to the modern R-comp race tire market, Hoosier currently owns it with very fast lap times and minimal con- cessions to street use—just enough to earn that DOT approval—although Goodyear recently rejoined the segment.

Hoosier R7

No buyer’s guide to motorsports tires would be complete without Hoosier. Availability in every size imaginable and a long record of success make it hard to bet against the crew from Indiana—should your rules and wallet permit. This tire is expensive and does heat-cycle out fairly quickly, but the lightning-quick response is without peer, as are the level and consistency of grip.

Hoosier A7

Want to go even faster? Here’s the top tire of all the DOT-approved R-comps. Stamped “Not for Highway Use” right there on the sidewall, this tire is optimized for one purpose only: going fast around cones or a road course. It doesn’t last long, sizing is more limited than the R7, and it will put a solid dent in your budget—but if you have the means, and your rules allow, it’s hard to bet against the A7.

Goodyear Eagle RS

After nearly a decade away, Goodyear has reentered the R-comp market, positioning its new Eagle RS as an alternative to the Hoosiers. We plan to test it soon.

Let Your Usage Be Your Guide

We’ve assembled this chart to be a quick reference to choose the proper tire for the proper venue.

  • Autocross: Choose A or AA for Warm-up and B or better for Pace.
  • Time trials: Choose by Pace and Wear.
  • Lapping days: Choose by Heat Tolerance and Wear.
  • Street and Track: Choose by Heat Tolerance, Wear and Wet.

Comments

View comments on the GRM forums

spacecadet (Forum Supporter)

Lots of interesting info here, and some stuff that I wasn’t aware of, like the return of the BFG Rival.

Thank you GRM for putting this together!

codrus (Forum Supporter)

Minor correction — the picture for the Nitto is of an NT-05, not an NT-01. 

Javelin (Forum Supporter)

I’m really excited to see what the new Continental/Hoosier collab tire does.

Thanks for this big test GRM! Now to go buy some more tires…

thashane

What is tread depth sensitivity? Tire performance in relation to wear?

 

These are tires that benefit significantly from shaving.  Wear to a lower depth will also help, but may put detrimental heat cycles on the tire at the same time.

wvumtnbkr

Anybody know where to get the coopers beside extreme?  They don’t have any in the 245 15 size in stock for the dry tire.

spacecadet (Forum Supporter)

thashane said:

What is tread depth sensitivity? Tire performance in relation to wear?

Tread block squirm… taller tread blocks are susecptible to moving or squirming and not having the responsiveness or wear that is most desirable.

SirCharlesC7

I am running CR1 in 245/40/15 in autocross and so far I really like them!

Very fast and consistent!

David S. Wallens

wvumtnbkr said:

Anybody know where to get the coopers beside extreme?  They don’t have any in the 245 15 size in stock for the dry tire.

Checking on that now for you.  

adam525i

Can we get a definitive answer to this question (if one exists)? Triangles on the sidewall. Wut?

Thanks!

dps214

Not officially a rollover indicator, though they do often tend to end up very close to the rubber seam (what you’re actually aiming for most of the time, using all of the tread rubber without getting into the sidewall rubber) and are a decent reference point as a result.

thashane

In reply to spacecadet (Forum Supporter) :

Got it thanks. Makes me think of LT tires, muds especially 

Floating Doc (Forum Supporter)

I’d like to see how the Firestone Firehawk Indy 500 compares to the Continental ECS and other tires in the non-200 TW summer performance class. I have a set on my street car and have been quite surprised at how well they grip, in both wet and dry conditions. 
 

If they were available in a 15 inch size, I would try them for an autocross rain tire on my Miata. 

malibuguy

Nothing about the Federal Pros eh?

I think they are just fantastic budget 200tw tire.  I am really happy with them

Andy Hollis

adam525i said:

Can we get a definitive answer to this question (if one exists)? Triangles on the sidewall. Wut?

Thanks!

They are there to indicate where to find the wear bars.  Triangles are most prevalent, but some manufacturers use other symbols.  There are articles on the web from various manufacturers stating such.  It has nothing to do with rollover.

NickD

NickD


MegaDork


7/6/21 10:08 a.m.

SirCharlesC7 said:

I am running CR1 in 245/40/15 in autocross and so far I really like them!

Very fast and consistent!

Similar experience. Also a very fun tire to drive on. 

captdownshift (Forum Supporter)

I want to see the RS3-RS tested against rally tires and snow tires in rallycross. I have a theory. 

Keith Tanner

The ultimate guide…until next year 🙂

Maybe I should revisit my choice of RR, this guide does not make them look like a good choice.  They do seem grippier under the V8 Miata than the NT01 and far better than the VR-1. That car is all about heat tolerance. 

Snrub

Snrub


Dork


7/6/21 1:11 p.m.

goingnowherefast

Keith Tanner said:

The ultimate guide…until next year 🙂

Maybe I should revisit my choice of RR, this guide does not make them look like a good choice.  They do seem grippier under the V8 Miata than the NT01 and far better than the VR-1. That car is all about heat tolerance. 

The Toyo RR’s were a good option a half decade ago, but seem to have fallen way behind. Although they don’t include data in this review (or maybe I can’t see it because I’m not currently subscribed) I’d bet that the RT660 are onpar or quicker than the RR’s while being WAY cheaper, and much more streetable. You’re right though, they are much better than the also super outdated NT01’s or VR-1’s (granted they sell 2 compounds, S1 &S2). I’d definitely try a modern tire next, as the 200 TW’s have caught up and exceeded many of the 100TW options. 

Keith Tanner

This is for a pure track tire on a high hp/wt car. Streetability isn’t important, “less fusssy and expensive than a Hoosier” is. Basically, I want RA1 ease of use with better grip 🙂 Last time I bought a set was a few years back.

I was pretty happy with the RE71R on a similar, more streetable application. I guess I should what’s available in my sizes. 

accordionfolder

I’m not sure why the rt-660 is labeled a great lapping tire? It’s a great TT or autoX tire, but it doesn’t hold up in the heat or repeated laps, maybe in really cold weather or fall? That’s not just my experience either, no one I talked to at TTNats had anything different to say about it. 

 

Olemiss540

Everyone can blast the “super outdated” NT01 but after all of these tests it just reaffirms my belief there isnt a better grip per dollar and least amount of fuss HPDE tire to slide around on to this day. Just set pressures and drive them for a long time while they stick better and better.

Keith Tanner

The NT01’s ancestor the RA1 is a total sweetheart of a tire and the NT01 shares many of its attributes. I am not blasting them, I have happily worn out many sets. My particular car (500 hp, 2400 lbs, Miata tire sizes) is awfully demanding on tires, though, and does respond to something with more grip.

¯_(ツ)_/¯

I would love to see a tarmac rally tire in this comparison, but I understand that there isn’t a huge market for them.  Still I wonder if the rally specific tarmac tires are worth it over a fast 200tw or a well grooved 100tw.

Vintage79

Looking for possible longer-wearing race tire alternative, but don’t want to crash finding it.

1 979 Fox Mustang with good suspension, benign behavior: Maximum Motorsports torque arm, Panhard bar, MM trailing arms, Penske shocks.  Now run Hoosier R7’s in 275-45-ZR16, which are excellent but limited for heat cycles and somewhat by wear rate.  If I’m willing to sacrifice some ultimate grip, is there a tire with similarly forgiving characteristics that are stable as it wears and heat cycles like the Hoosiers are, that might give more than 8-10 (12 on a good day now) good heat cycles and retain the benign handling characteristics of the Hoosiers at slightly lower limits?  Avoiding tires that break away abruptly at any point in their life is an important goal.

Thanks

rsotak

Any feedback on the Hankook Z214?  Looking to get heat cycle information and overall speed versus R7

Duke

Duke


MegaDork


8/10/21 8:42 a.m.

rsotak said:

Any feedback on the Hankook Z214?  Looking to get heat cycle information and overall speed versus R7

I’ve asked that question for several years, but apparently nobody runs them, because I never get an answer.  They seem like a decently-priced alternative and they come in several compounds.

 

accordionfolder

accordionfolder said:

I’m not sure why the rt-660 is labeled a great lapping tire? It’s a great TT or autoX tire, but it doesn’t hold up in the heat or repeated laps, maybe in really cold weather or fall? That’s not just my experience either, no one I talked to at TTNats had anything different to say about it. 

 

Ran them again recently (Another PB! They are fast…)High 70’s/low 80’s they seem to be holding up a lot better. Still not as consistent as I’d like, but they don’t have the same cliff as when it was high 80’s/low 90’s.

jbrauer11

In reply to rsotak :

Interesting they didn’t include them at all.  Poor Hankook, always the red headed step child of the R comp class.

Colin Wood

Just bumping this since we updated the guide after testing the Kumho ECSTA V730 against the Yokohama Advan A052.

David S. Wallens

rsotak said:

Any feedback on the Hankook Z214?  Looking to get heat cycle information and overall speed versus R7

Priced well but, from what we have seen, not as fast as an R7 or BFG R1. 

David S. Wallens

Also, coming soon: endurance test of the new Continental ExtremeContactForce–the “Hoosier” 200tw tire. 

TrentO

TrentO


New Reader


10/20/21 11:23 a.m.

Would like to see a a comparison of the leading slicks on the market. Michelin vs Yokohama vs Pirelli vs Hoosier vs Avon vs Goodyear. Both radial and bias ply. Bias in the GT3 cantilevered and the radials in 18″ sizes. (260-300 tread width)

 

Trent

kevlarcorolla

In reply to David S. Wallens :

Hoping for a true endurance test not just 5 extra laps of a 30 second cone course 🙂

David S. Wallens

In reply to kevlarcorolla :

How about 1 hour per tire? Coming up in the next issue. smiley





Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

thirty  ⁄  fifteen  =